Shankar Sharma, Vice-Chairman and Joint Managing Director, First Global, does not expect the current rally to continue for more than a week. “The market would see a huge sell-off by mid-December, which may continue till January end.”
He estimates a 20-30% sell-of in markets during the next 3-4 months and sees a durable rally only after the next fall.
Sharma foresees an earnings downtrend in FY10. “We see that fiscal year being worse than FY09 for the markets.”
Sharma feels the monetary easing would not boost the market significantly and said the markets may at best rally for 1-2 days. He added that the fiscal package under discussion was too little to make a difference.
He believes the elections could compound the current situation and would be a dampener.
Here is a verbatim transcript of the exclusive interview with Shankar Sharma on CNBC-TV18. Also watch the accompanying video.
Q: One of you recent reports was talking a pullback or a temporary pullback in equities. Has that come and gone with that five-six day rally that we saw just a few days back or do you think its still pending?
A: We issued this report a week before the last and globally markets did rally about 10-12% from the lows
Markets will not discount this substantial in advance so I reckon somewhere in the middle of the month i.e. this month the market will begin to get a sense of how bad their numbers are going to be and I wouldn’t be surprise if a few major companies across the world came out and issue earnings warnings that they are not going to be able to meet the numbers that they had forecasted for this quarter. Therefore we see market beginning to sell off probably in the middle of December and this could continue I reckon to the middle of January or end of January.
This month could be as ugly as October because I do not think the markets have factored in how bad the numbers in this quarter going to be globally. The October sell off was largely due to the Lehman bankruptcy and how it affected the credit market. But the credit market effect on the real economy will now be visible once these numbers begin to come out and we all know anecdotally how bad numbers in
Q: What is your sense of how ugly it could get in December-January? Do you think it is a revisit of the October lows or could it get worse than that?
That leads me to believe the markets will probably see a more durable rally because one of the strange things about this bear market has been that the rallies have not been durable, they haven’t even lasted for 30-45 days, they are over in 5-10 or 15 days.
A durable rally will probably succeed a pretty severe fall which begins in the next few days time.
So that is the way we think the markets are set up. They have not fully discounted the bad numbers anywhere in the world. Analysts’ estimates are still way too high and I think this quarter will knock some sense into all those numbers.
Q: In the short-term, how high would you rate the chances that the market actually settles into a range is very boring for the next few weeks does nothing?
A: I don’t think any range has lasted more than a few days. The markets have been very strongly trending markets this year as they were in the last four-five years. The trading ranges have been in consolidation phases before markets breakout in whatever direction they have been trading in.
So when there was a bull market, the consolidations were very short. There were very sharp, short pullbacks and then markets would continue going up. This time the pullbacks while they may not have been that sharp, there have been few pullbacks of a few days duration and then they continue going down.
So I don’t think there is any trading range or any such situation developing at all. Merely because the markets don’t do much for three days, it starts to build theories that it is in a trading range but I don’t think that is a real possibility.
Q: There is the promise of course now of fiscal action and monetary action coming together. How much does that translate into for the market in real terms you think?
A: Maybe a day’s rally, maybe two days. One should remember this is like a Morphine shot you need greater and greater Morphine shots in order to kill the pain and that is the way this thing works.
The first one will lead to greater euphoria and each successive injection whether it is monetary or fiscal – in economics they call it the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility and that is the way markets look at such stimuli packages.
So globally, the first ones (packages) did a lot of good in terms of market action and then successively markets say that nothing is working and it is just another stimulus package.
I don’t think it conveys a very good picture to the world that our neighbour is putting up a USD 550 billion package and here we are announcing a USD 10 billion package. It doesn’t seem right. They may as well not announce and on a subterranean basis — keep doing what you are doing on a slightly accelerated basis — why make a big song and dance about something which is like 2% of what
Q: How are you reading 2009 now if there is a big fall or big leg down coming around the January numbers after that how do you see the rest of 2009?
A: The numbers in FY10 will be substantially worse. The slowdown has accelerated post the middle of the calendar year 2009. So we have had more or less five-six months of reasonable earnings growth and reasonable GDP (Gross Domestic Product) growth coming and that’s not going to be replicable for the rest of the financial year and the calendar year of 2009. Our sense if FY10 will be definitely a down year in terms of earnings for
So I am pretty certain and its early days to start making definitive forecast in FY10 but our take is you will definitely see a down earnings in FY10. Globally, it will be pretty much the same case; corporate earnings that was strong for last five years will be decimated. Sector wise; semiconductors are hurting, retail is hurting, banks are obviously gone.
The world’s earnings composition also changes in every phase of a bull market. The last five years globally the market was driven largely by the commodity cyclical and they became large part of the indexes worldwide and they became even larger part of earnings growth worldwide. Now that sector is gone, oil is at USD 45/bbl and it can easily hit USD 20 print in the next six-eight months time. Exxon Mobil, iron ore or steel were all the big drivers of earnings growth but those are not going to come back for many years in terms of earnings growth.
You might well see a situation where they might make losses 12 months from now because it is our view that commodity prices will breach the lows of 2002. I am talking about the absolute commodity prices, which means that the stocks of those commodities so whether it is BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto or Exxon Mobil, Companhia Vale do Rio Doce (CVRD) or Indian metal companies should all trade lower than their prices of 2002-03, in terms of the absolute stock price. When the commodity price breaches the lows of 2002 the stocks of those companies will trade even lower because these companies have upped their risk in the last five years. They have gone and made acquisitions, they have leveraged their balance sheets up. Rio Tinto has got USD 46 billion of debt and that is a lot of debt built up in the last few years and about USD 8-10 billion is coming due in the next 12 months time.
These companies are far riskier than they were at the trough of the commodity cycle. So when you hit another trough, these stocks will go down even lower and therefore the earnings will obviously be linked to the trough. I don’t see how that earnings growth is going to be replicable out of the same pack. So may be some other pack has to emerge and it is too early in this bear market to start talking of the sector, which balances out the negatives of the commodity cyclical.
Q: At the very start of the conversation, you mentioned autos, what would you do with that whole pocket?
A: Autos are symptomatic of what the real problems are. So, as far as the real economy is concerned, these numbers are mind-bogglingly terrible numbers and I don’t see how this thing will revive or turnaround that quickly.
Companies like a Hero Honda or a Maruti don’t have much leverage. They are not going to be in a financial stress if the market continues to be as bad as it is. But you have other leveraged auto companies and I just fear that leverage with these kind of poor numbers, interest cost, interest burden none of those things are a good cocktail. They are a very lethal cocktail and the sector is in deep strife.